Deciding What’s Best for Your Family: Comparing the Different Methods of Homeschooling


Homeschooling is becoming more and more popular as an education option for families around the world. With the flexibility of homeschooling, parents can create an educational program that is tailored to their children’s individual learning style and unique needs. However, there are different methods of homeschooling that cater to different goals and objectives of the home schooler. In order to choose the best method for your family, it is important to understand the different approaches and styles of homeschooling that are available.

The most common methods of homeschooling are structured, traditional, Charlotte Mason, Eclectic, Unschooling, Classical, and Montessori. With the Structured approach parents create a workbook/textbook-style program, assigning and assessing various different subjects and material at their child’s own pace. The Traditional approach follows a traditional grading system and mimics a classroom structure with individual subjects being tested and graded. The Charlotte Mason approach focuses on storytelling, journaling, and nature study. With this method, parents combine education with real life experiences, exposing children to outside activity and nature as an educational tool. The Eclectic approach allows parents to pick and choose from different methods and materials, such as textbooks, video courses, and activities, to create a learning environment that works for their children. The Unschooling approach is a student driven method where the children take the lead in their education, choosing what they want to learn and when they want to learn it. This method highly values curiosity, creativity, and personal interests, as it believes that children learn best when they are deeply engaged and passionate about the subject matter.


Homeschooling is an educational choice that allows parents or guardians to educate their children outside of a traditional classroom setting. It is up to the parent or guardian to decide how their homeschooling program should be structured. The most common methods of homeschooling are Eclectic, Traditional, Traditional with Modifications, Unschooling, and Virtual/Online. When deciding which homeschooling method to choose, it is important to consider the learning needs and interests of your child. Eclectic homeschooling allows parents to create a tailored learning environment for their child by picking and choosing materials, approaches, and techniques from different teaching methods. Traditional homeschooling replicates the structure of a traditional school setting, but with more parental involvement in lesson plans and student assessments. Traditional with Modifications homeschooling is similar to traditional but allows for more flexibility and creativity in lesson plans. Unschooling allows children to learn through autonomous activities and self-directed exploration. Virtual or Online homeschooling entails enrolling in a virtual academy or other online program in which the instruction and assignments are mostly delivered electronically. Ultimately, the best method of homeschooling to choose depends on your child’s learning style and your comfort level with different teaching methods.

Different Types of Homeschooling 

There are several different types of homeschooling programs and methodologies available to parents, each with their own unique approach to teaching. The most common types are described below:

1. Traditional: The most commonly used form of homeschooling, traditional homeschooling typically involves one parent teaching the student lessons with textbooks and worksheets. Parents create lesson plans, find and use references and resources to teach their children, and evaluate their student’s knowledge and progress.

2. Classical: This approach focuses heavily on the Great Books of Western Civilization as a primary learning source. It emphasizes the value of memorization, offers a multi-year schedule of study, and may include the teaching of Latin and Greek.

3. Charlotte Mason: Described as “gentle learning,” this method focuses on providing children with living books rather than textbooks, and encouraging them to form personal relationships with the material. Learning activities include nature walks, handicrafts, and other natural activities.

4. Montessori: Primarily focused on self-directed learning, Montessori homeschooling uses materials and activities that stimulate sensory learning. Parents provide guidance and a stimulating environment rather than direct teaching.

5. Unschooling: Unschooling is a child-led form of homeschooling that eliminates most structured lessons and follows the child’s interests and passions. This approach relies heavily on the parent allowing their child to explore and learn at their own pace, promoting an intrinsic love for learning. The parent’s role transitions from a traditional teacher to a facilitator or guide, providing support, resources, and an enriching environment conducive to learning.

Traditional Homeschooling 

Traditional homeschooling is one of several methods of homeschooling available, and is a form of homeschooling that is loosely based on a standard school curriculum. It focuses on the more traditional aspects of education, including literature, mathematics, science, and history, and follows the same academic year structure as a typical school would. This method of homeschooling is best for those who prefer a more structured learning environment, and is a great choice for those preferring a more traditional setting for their children’s education. For those looking for a homeschooling experience that allows for more personalization and exploration, however, traditional homeschooling may not be the best option.

Online Homeschooling 

Online homeschooling is a form of homeschooling where the curriculum is delivered via the internet, rather than through traditional teaching methods. This form of homeschooling has become increasingly popular in recent years due to its convenience, cost-effectiveness, and flexibility.

When it comes to online homeschooling, there are several different methods to choose from. Depending on the student’s learning style, one method might be better suited than another. Some of the most common methods include:

• Online Courses – These are designed to supplement the traditional curriculum and allow the student to receive a more personalized teaching experience.

• Online Resources – These typically include blogs, websites, and virtual classrooms that provide the student with materials and advice on how to complete their coursework.

• Virtual Tutoring – This is a great option for students who need help with a particular subject. Tutors work with students one-on-one using video chat and often have an in-depth knowledge of the subject that they are teaching.

• Self-study – This method involves the student researching the material on their own and then performing assignments to demonstrate their progress.

When choosing a method of online homeschooling, it is important to keep in mind the student’s individual learning style and level of motivation. Some students may be better suited to a self-study approach, while others might prefer the structure of a more traditional classroom setting.


Unschooling 

Unschooling is an educational philosophy which encourages parents to allow their children to find their own interests and pursue those interests within a self-directed learning environment. Unschooling is founded on the idea that each child is an individual with unique interests and learning styles, and they have the capacity to learn best when given the freedom to explore their interests and the world around them. Unschoolers typically do not use a traditional curriculum but instead focus on hands-on learning, project-based learning, experimentation, and self-directed exploration. Unschooling is rarely focused on obtaining a particular grade in a course, as the goal is to have the student learn by his or her own experiences in life. This method of home schooling is most suitable for an independent and self-motivated learner who is able to find the resources to satisfy their curiosity and curiosities.

Institutional Homeschooling 

Institutional homeschooling is a form of homeschooling in which children are taught at an institution, such as a private school, religious school, or online program. The classes may be offered either in person or online and parents can choose what classes they wish their children to take. Institutional homeschooling offers the advantage of having students receive instruction from experienced teachers, often with backgrounds in the subject matter being taught. The disadvantage of institutional homeschooling is that it tends to be more expensive than other forms of homeschooling, and parents may need to spend more time and energy researching the best options for their children. Ultimately, the “right” choice depends on the needs and goals of each individual family.

Factors to Consider When Selecting a Homeschool Method 

There are many different methods of homeschooling that can be tailored to suit the individual needs and goals of the family and the student. These methods can range from traditional textbook and lecture style instruction to modern, online-oriented, progressive learning styles. It’s important to take the time to research and understand the different curricula styles and approaches available so you can determine which one is the best fit for you and your family.

Some of the main considerations when selecting a homeschooling method include the following:

1. Your student’s learning style and education goals. Does your student prefer hands-on or visual activities? Is their goal to go on to college? Knowing your student’s education goals and their learning preferences can help you determine the best homeschooling method.

2. Your family’s lifestyle and philosophy. It’s important to identify how you and your family want to approach learning. Are you more traditional or experimental in your teaching style? Do you prefer online resources or experiential activities in learning?

3. Your available resources. It’s beneficial to identify what resources you have available to support learning. Consider your budget and the amount of time you have to dedicate to homeschooling. Which methods can you realistically commit to?

4. Your local or state homeschooling laws. Different states have different laws when it comes to homeschooling. Check your state’s education website or consult with a local homeschooling organization to understand the specific requirements and regulations for homeschooling in your area.

The Resources Available 

The resources available to you depend on the specific method of homeschooling you choose. Generally, resources can include curricula, textbooks, library resources, educational software, online classes, learning materials from museums and other educational institutions, educational field trips, and support materials from other home-schooling parents. You should also consider joining a support group to provide resources to help you stay organized and offer support from a local homeschooling community. It is important to find a method that works best with your family, certain educational philosophies, and specific learning styles.

Available Time 

One method of determining which homeschooling option is best for you and your child is to consider your available time. Every homeschooling style requires a different level of parent involvement and planning, as well as varies in the amount of instructional time required. Traditional homeschooling requires more of a hands-on approach, as parents are responsible for selecting and teaching the curriculum. On the other hand, online and hybrid homeschooling require a much smaller time commitment from parents. They can choose curriculum already created and organized by experienced teachers, often with supplemental guidance. Additionally, some options are better for busy or working parents, such as virtual and hybrid learning which minimize the parent-child instructional time commitment. Before you make a decision, consider how much time you have available for homeschooling and what type of program will fit within your schedule.

Parents Comfort Level 

When considering which homeschooling method to choose, it is important for parents to consider their own comfort level with each method. Consider such factors as how much preparation and work are needed, what type of curriculum is most compatible with your values, as well as the level of involvement you are comfortable with. You may be most comfortable with a traditional model of homeschooling, which bases instruction on textbooks and follows a set curriculum, or you may prefer an unobtrusive model, such as the Montessori approach or unschooling, where the student drives the learning experiences. If a hybrid approach works best for you, you may combine elements from more than one model. Different homeschoolers require different levels of commitment and preparation, so it is important to find the method or methods that work best for you.

Your Child’s Learning Style 

There are many methods of homeschooling and the right choice for you and your child will depend on your child’s individual learning style. Some common methods include Unschooling, which advocates for students to learn by pursuing their own interests, Charlotte Mason, which emphasizes classical education and literature, Unit Studies, which explores interdisciplinary subjects, and Montessori, which encourages self-paced directed learning.

Before deciding on any particular method, it is important to understand your child’s academic strengths and weaknesses, as well as their distinct learning preferences. Are they a visual learner? Or do they prefer kinesthetic and experiential approaches? If they are an auditory learner, then the Montessori method might be a great fit. By understanding their strengths and interests, you can better decide which curricula and method will be most successful.


Your Family’s Values 

Your family’s values and lifestyle are an important piece of the puzzle when it comes to making a decision on which homeschooling method to use. Depending on the values and lifestyle you wish to uphold, some of the more popular homeschooling methods are Classical, Charlotte Mason, Unschooling, and Thomas Jefferson Education. Classical homeschooling focuses on teaching through the Trivium stages of grammar, logic, and rhetoric, providing students with a foundation of knowledge upon which to build, and often involves memorization and recitation exercises. Charlotte Mason homeschooling emphasizes quality over quantity in terms of education, utilizing books and literature for instruction and studying subjects thoroughly. Unschooling is a type of self-directed learning that values freedom, creativity, and hands-on experiences. It encourages the student to explore and discover on their own without set structured methods. Thomas Jefferson Education homeschooling promotes the critical thinking and communication skills of the student through classic readings and projects. Ultimately, the homeschool method that is chosen should align with your family’s values and lifestyle, while also meeting the needs of the student. If you can find a balance between structure and freedom that works for everyone, you should have no trouble finding the best homeschooling method for your family!

Final Thoughts

Ultimately, the method of homeschooling that you decide to pursue should be based on your personal preferences, and the needs and abilities of your child. Some parents prefer a traditional classroom approach with structured classes and lessons, while others might opt for a more homeschool-as-life style with hands-on projects and a flexible curriculum. It is also important to take into consideration any available resources, such as online tutors or classes, as well as other parents who are homeschooling, in order to find the right fit for you and your child.

Homeschooling offers parents and students a variety of methods to choose from. There are options tailored to different preferences, needs, and learning styles, such as classical, Charlotte Mason, Montessori, unit study, eclectic, unschooling, and multiple intelligence approaches. Each method may have its own unique system of curriculum and instruction that emphasizes different aspects or techniques. It is important to research and learn about the various methods to determine which one is the best fit for you and your student. Understanding the different methods of homeschooling will help you decide which one is the best for you and your family.

There is no single method of homeschooling that is ideal for everyone; it really depends on individual circumstances and preferences. It is important to consider factors like the age and learning style of your child, your own teaching style, and the resources you have available. As you research the different types of homeschooling, look for what will best meet the needs of your family. Ultimately, the method of homeschooling you choose should be one that provides the best educational experience for your child and that works best for your family.

Recent Posts